Taariq Clarke v The Queen

Download PDF
Case NumberAppeal No. 8 of 2015
CourtCourt of Appeal
JudgeBaker
Document TypeEx Tempore Judgment
PlaintiffTAARIQ CLARKE
DefendantTHE QUEEN
Counsel (Defendant)Loxley Ricketts, Department
Firm (Defendant)Public Prosecutions
Summary BETA

Outcome: Allowed

Held: A 50% discount on sentence should ordinarily be applied where a defendant gives sworn evidence in the High Court leading to conviction of a co-defendant, rather than a lesser discount for other forms of police assistance.

Taariq Clarke appealed his sentence of 7½ years for aggravated burglary and using a firearm. The sentencing judge had imposed a 35% discount on a 12-year baseline for police assistance. Clarke sought application of the ordinary practice of a 50% discount based on his sworn testimony in the High Court leading to a co-defendant's conviction. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and reduced the sentence to 6 years.

Sentencing Criminal procedure Aggravated burglary Firearms offences Assistance to prosecution

AI-generated; may contain errors.

Other Judgments in this Matter 1
Full Text

The Court of Appeal for Bermuda

CRIMINAL APPEAL No 8 of 2015

Between:

TAARIQ CLARKE

Appellant

v

THE QUEEN

Respondent

Before: Baker, President Bell, JA Kawaley, AJA Appearances: Mr. Charles Richardson, Compass Law Chambers, for the Appellant Mr. Loxley Ricketts, Department of Public Prosecutions, for the Respondent Date of Hearing & Judgment: 15 March 2016

EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT

Appeal against sentence of 7 ½ years' imprisonment reduced to 6 for aggravated burglary and using a firearm – assistance to the police – given evidence leading to a conviction - early plea of guilty

PRESIDENT

1. This is an appeal by Taariq Clarke on the basis that he was sentenced by Justice Greaves to seven and a half years' imprisonment for aggravated burglary and using a firearm to commit the offence which reflected a discount of about 35% on a sentence that would have been twelve years' imprisonment, but for the fact that he had given assistance to the police in the shape of a caution statement that in the event ultimately led to another person being apprehended and convicted of the crime. It is urged on the Court that in accordance with the ordinary practice he should now be entitled to the full discount of 50%, the consequence of which would reduce the sentence of seven and a half years' imprisonment to six years' imprisonment, that being on the ground that he gave sworn testimony in the High Court which led to the conviction of a co-defendant.

2. We see no reason to depart from the ordinary practice, nor do we see that there is any necessity to describe in any detail the circumstances of the offence. The circumstances can be seen by looking at the judgment recently given by this Court in The Queen v Umdae Woolridge Criminal Appeal 12 of 2015.

3. The appeal is accordingly allowed and the sentence of seven and a half years reduced to six years. In other respects, the order below stands. Signed _______________________________ Baker, P